No Bake Freezer Lactation Cookies {UPDATE}

This post contains affiliate links. Click here to read my affiliate policy.

We started with a post called Katrina’s no bake Lactation Cookies. There was some confusion with this recipe because my photos of the cookies I made were much different from the images Katrina supplied us with. I had some complaints that the cookies were not turning out like the photos. I want to apologize for this & not being more clear as to why there was such a difference.

When I was making Katrina’s cookies, I didn’t have enough oats, nor did I have the same oats Katrina was using. I had to toss my cookies directly in the freezer and keep them there in order for them to stay solid. They soften up enough to eat with a spoon when I de-thaw them.

So, with that being said, here is the recipe I used & we can title them freezer cookies because that’s where they will need to stay if you want them to look like the images! 😉

For more solid, cookie textured versions, check out Katrina’s recipes on our first post.

No Bake Freezer Lactation Cookies {UPDATE}

For these cookies, I put scoops of the mix onto parchment paper on a cookie sheet and placed the tray in the freezer. Once they were frozen, I placed them into an airtight Ziplock freezer bag & kept them in the freezer.

Below I will share the recipe with what I used. I had to work with what I had on hand which wasn’t exactly what Katrina was calling for.

Note: This version needs to stay in the freezer or they will melt.

The Recipe:

Base Recipe:

Additional add-ins: flax seeds, brewer’s yeast or fenugreek for extra boosting properties. See the original post for Katrina’s version including flax & chia seeds.

To Make:

Line cookie sheet with parchment paper. Or Use a silicone mold.

Bring the sugar, milk, coconut oil and cocoa to a boil in a medium saucepan over medium heat, stirring occasionally, then let boil for 1 minute.

Remove from the heat.

Add the oats, peanut butter, vanilla and salt, and stir to combine.

Spoon onto parchment or into mold, let cool for 10-20 mins and put the tray directly into freezer.

Once the cookies are solid you can pop them out of the mold or off of the parchment paper, place in an airtight freezer safe zip-seal bag & store in freezer.

Pop one or two out and enjoy. I usually toss one in a bowl and let it de-thaw a bit and eat it with a spoon but you can absolutely eat from frozen as well.

I also like to mix them with yogurt & bananas. Or frozen yogurt! 🙂

For these cookies, I scooped my mixture into a silicone cupcake tray. I then put the tray directly in the freezer and when they were solid, I popped them out and straight into an airtight Zip-seal bag and kept them in the freezer. There is a photo of the tray I used with a link to purchase online below.

Here is the silicone tray I used to make the circle cookies in the main photo. You can find these online here.


Store in zipper seal, freezer safe baggies, in the freezer.

Happy Lactating! 😉

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (2 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)

Share with friends

Briar Rose

Briar Rose - Canadian Mama to two beautiful boys, blessed wife to the most supportive husband, Positive Parenting, Natural Family Wellness & Motherhood. Saved by Grace, Lover of all things old. Antiques, Old Books and Old Homes. History and Ancestry. Refinishing or Restoring Furniture, Creating Rustic Designs, Ornate Antique, Primitive Decorating. Learning to bake, sharing on Old Recipe Book. Taking a break from Blogging @ Briar Rose Blog, The Herbal Healing Mama, & Rustic Reclaimed Designs. - Profile photo: Reflections of Life Photography.

View all posts by Briar Rose →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *